If I could ban one phrase from the American lexicon, it would be: “But I support the troops.” It’s shorthand for “I don’t support this war, but I also don’t want a bunch of Americans to die.” Well, who in this country does want a bunch of Americans to die? (I’m excluding members of any al-Qaeda sleeper cells here.) It’s silly that people feel they have to say it.

The whole reason for the phrase is the idea that in Vietnam, the general public somehow didn’t support the troops — that opposition to that war wasn’t against policies in Washington, but somehow against actual soldiers. The tale this always comes back to involves soldiers getting spit on when they returned home from the front lines.

Too bad it’s not even true.

26 March 2003



Comments

27 March | 9:34  |  mike

any second now, someone's going to post "but it DID happen. really. my uncle got spit on when he came back from the war."

27 March | 10:36  |  billy

I always suspected those stories were apocryphal -but as the piece states, you can't prove a negative.

Still - it did raise a question for me. How much fact-checking is considered "enough" in modern journalism?

27 March | 11:11  |  Tam

Here I go proving Mike right.

My dad was one of 9 and the only son of age who went to Vietnam instead of Canada (like the rest of his brothers). When he did return, he was treated very badly by the people who should have supported him the most, his own family. I always gloss over this fact because it sickens me to know my own family is that disgusting... but it DID happen, and I have 8 corroborating witnesses. (My dad says they spit on him and generally attempted to beat the snot out of him... none of my uncles disagreed with this fact. Actually, most of them attempted to embellish their roles.)

27 March | 15:47  |  mike

you cant have it both ways...the war is going , protesting it does nobody any good. when did protesting become so sheik? can someone please tell all of these hollyweird losers to shut their traps, WE DONT GIVE A S*IT WHAT A BUNCH OF RICH, OUT OF TOUCH, M*F'S THINK ABOUT WAR....at least i don't.

28 March | 13:32  |  Jonny B.

er, sheik? man, i hope that was an intentional pun...

01 April | 11:18  |  anna

mike, you need to take a deep breath. who said celebrities can't have a valuable opinion? after all, we did elect one as president (don't tell me you forgot about reagan the ACTOR).

josh, i think the problem here is the way the media has framed this thing. they consistently characterise the demonstrations as "anti-war" or "support the troops" as if the two thoughts were mutually exclusive.

02 April | 14:23  |  Chuck

Another reason some people feel they have to say it is that this is a time when people are being assaulted for expressing anti-war views.



Post a comment




    Remember Me?




Joshua Benton is the director of the Nieman Digital Journalism Project at Harvard University, among other things. Before that, he was a staff writer and columnist for The Dallas Morning News. (More.)

Links

About | Archives | Contact | Writing | Photos | Links | Wish

RSS feeds  

Blog posts
News articles

Recently played tracks

Most recent stories

06 Aug: COLUMN: A year’s wait can make all the difference for your child

29 Jul: TEA hears Lancaster’s 4-day school plan, considers audit; District’s finances raise concerns in waiver push

28 Jul: Lancaster ISD still lags behind; TAKS scores are higher since ‘03, but increases among D-FW’s smallest

Archives

Search

Disclaimer

Any opinions expressed here are solely mine, and not those of my employer. In many cases, they may not even be mine.

 
Archives | RSS | © 2001-2006 Joshua Benton